by Peter Blood-Patterson
This course was originally taught at Pendle Hill during spring term on 2025 under the title: “Primitive Quakerism Revived: Returning to Friends’ Roots as a Radically Transformative Prophetic Movement”.
Table of contents
- Course description
- Class 1 – The Seed Christ is over all
- Class 2 – The Breaking Forth of That Power
- Class 3 – Gospel Order
- Class 4 – Holding Each Other in Love & Truth
- Class 5 – This Is Our Testimony to the World
- Appendix: Psalm 32 Re-imagined (for Friends)
- About the class and teacher
Course description
In England during the second half of the 17th century, God drew together an extraordinary movement of people united in a shared understanding of how to live with each other faithfully in truth and love, guided by the immediate revelation of God to their community. The Children of the Light or Publishers of Truth (as they called themselves) carried a prophetic vision of God’s hopes for how people can live with each other here on earth. That vision contrasted sharply with the values and assumptions of the established church, the state, and the economic system of the day.
That early Quaker movement looked and acted very differently from all the branches and variants of this Society of Friends today. In this course, we will do a deep dive into what that early Friends community was about, where and how Friends have departed from their faith and witness, and how Friends today might once again be a transformative prophetic force in the world around us capable of “shaking the earth for ten miles around”.
We will walk together with selected writings by early Quaker women and men and of modern Friends like Sandra Cronk, Thomas Kelly, Marcelle Martin, and Paul Buckley (whose 2018 book Primitive Quakerism Revived gave this course its original title). Most of these readings are on Inward Light, the online library on Quakerism that I am helping build. (You can also find many more readings there on each subject we are covering.)
Organization of the course. We will look at specific areas of Quaker faith and practice in each of the five classes — exploring what we believe characterized early Friends’ approach to each area. We will not spend a lot of time ruminating on how Friends strayed from those early beginnings, but focus instead on how Friends today might live into the life and power that characterized our Quaker forebears.
How Friends Began. If you are not very familiar with early Quaker history (the period from the establishment of the first meetings in the late 1640s through the Act of Toleration in 1688) I encourage you to take this opportunity to do some background reading about the beginnings of our Quaker movement. We will not spend a ton of time on Quaker history in this class per se. We will spend time at the beginning of each session focusing in on early Friends’ beliefs and communal life in the particular area being addressed. Having a broader general view will be very helpful. This will be particularly helpful if you are not a Friend!
- An easy read for this period that is available online is Leonard Kenworthy’s
Quakerism in the 17th century: George Fox & the Early Friends – if you know relatively little about early Friends I suggest and/or Brinton (below) as a great place to start. (about 15pp.) - The Quaker Discovery by Thomas Kelly is a short heart-felt piece about George Fox’s discovery of an immediate powerful direct relationship with God. (about 6pp.)
- Chapter 2 “In the Beginning” of Primitive Quakerism Revived by Paul Buckley. (Note: Paul will be attending this course as a guest.) The descriptions of “The God or Spirit of World”, “The Lamb’s War”, and the “Kingdom of God on Earth” I find especially helpful and important. (The early Quaker ideas about “Salvation” and “Perfection” are also important but often hard for modern Friends to wrap their heads around!) (about 12pp.)
- Handouts for the “Revolutionary Roots of Quakerism”(10pp.), a course on early Quakers. See especially #1 on The World Turned Upside Down (background & beginnings) The following two books are also great histories. They may be in your meeting library (or your own!) If not, these can both be read online if you create a free Internet Archive account:
- John Punshon, A Portrait in Gray, chaps 2-4, espec. Ch. 3
- Howard Brinton, Friends for 300 Years pp,175-181: a brief summary of Quakerism’s 1st period
Primitive Quakerism Revived. This course was inspired by the book with this title by Paul Buckley. Paul has graciously agreed to take part in this course (via zoom) but is not responsible for its content!
We will not be using his book as a text but it may be helpful to have a look at the Introduction, particularly where he lists 10 reasons he believes Quakerism needs to be revived and his list of “Disclosures” — the biases or assumptions he brought to writing this book — since the first 6 of these are ones that I also bring to planning and teaching this course. You do not need to share these assumptions to be welcome in this course, but it will help you to know that I (and Paul) do have these assumptions to our hope for a revival of “primitive Quakerism”. If you can, a number of the sections of this book will be helpful throughout the course. See the Table of Contents of Paul’s book.
Class #1 – The Seed Christ Is Over All:
Knowing God “Experimentally”
Readings:
We will explore what many consider to be the heart of Quaker faith & practice, i.e. the direct unmediated relationship we seek with God as a community (i.e. not as individuals).
- Louise Wilson, Keynote Address to the Friends Consultation on Spiritual Authority & Accountability. a wonderfully fresh personal account of the voice of God as it came to her & her family! From the report of the Friends Consultation on Spiritual Authority & Accountability (about 9pp.)
- Paul Lacey, The Authority of Our Meetings Is in the Power of God by — read whole Pendle Hill pamphlet if possible — or at least thru section on “Answering That of God in Everyone” (6pp)
Additional readings:
- Thomas Kelly, The Quaker Discovery describes George Fox’s experience of receiving “experimental” first-hand knowledge of and his growing intimate relationship with God.
- Paul Buckley, on “The Light”: the first section of Chapter 3 of Primitive Quakerism Revived.
- Sam Caldwell, The Inward Light: How Quakerism Unites Universalism & Christianity.
- Geoffrey Nuttall’s 1959 Pendle Hill pamphlet To the Refreshing of the Children of the Light — a fascinating appeal to modern Friends to “return to our roots” from an English Christian!
- The Light Within opening section of the 2018 Faith & Practice of Philadelphia YM (only 1 page)
- Revolutionary Roots handout #2 on This I Knew Experimentally (ideas about God & the Bible)
- Inward Light section on The Light Within: inwardlight.org/faith/light
Class Handout:
In view of many Friends, the unique heart of Quaker faith and practice is the experience that God is directly available to our faith community at all times. As Friends we believe God is available to teach us and lead us as a community (not just as individuals) in our worship, our decisions as a meeting, our “testimonies” (both in terms of how we live and our witness to the world around us), and as the leadings, gifts, and ministries that God calls us to carry out.
Here is the way Frances Howgill described the early Friends experience of the Light working amongst them:
The Kingdom of Heaven did gather us and catch us all, as in a net, and his heavenly power at one time drew many hundreds to land. We came to know a place to stand in and what to wait in; and the Lord appeared daily to us, to our astonishment, amazement and great admiration, insomuch that we often said one unto another with great joy of heart: “What, is the Kingdom of God come to be with men? And will he take up his tabernacle among the sons of men, as he did of old? Shall we… have this honour of glory communicated amongst us, which were but men of small parts and of little abilities, in respect of many others, as amongst men?”
And from that day forward, our hearts were knit unto the Lord and one unto another in true and fervent love, in the covenant of Life with God; and that was a strong obligation or bond upon all our spirits, which united us one unto another.
Here is how George Fox described this:
I declared Truth amongst them, and directed them to the light of Christ in them; testifying unto them that God was come to teach His people Himself, whether they would hear or forbear. I directed the people to their inward Teacher, Christ Jesus, who would turn them from darkness to the light….
Therefore I exhorted the people to come off all these things, and directed them to the spirit and grace of God in themselves, and to the light of Jesus in their own hearts, that they might come to know Christ, their free Teacher, to bring them salvation, and to open the Scriptures to them….
And when all my hopes in them and in all men were gone, so that I had nothing outwardly to help me, nor could tell what to do, then, Oh then, I heard a voice which said, “There is one, even Christ Jesus, that can speak to thy condition,” and when I heard it my heart did leap for joy…. And this I knew experimentally.
Early Friends most often spoke of this Inward Teacher as Christ, drawing in part on the first chapter of John:
In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God. All things came into being through him, and without him not one thing came into being. What has come into being in him was life, and the life was the light of all people. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not overtake it… The true light, which enlightens everyone, was coming into the world.
In John 4, Jesus tells a Samaritan woman at a well, “If you knew the gift of God and who it is that asks you for a drink, you would have asked him and he would have given you living water.”
In John 8:12, Jesus says “I am the light of the world. Whoever follows me will never walk in darkness but will have the light of life.”
Queries:
- Have you experienced God speaking directly to you either alone or in community?
- How do you see God’s onward work among Friends as being the same or different from in the 17th century?
- How might Friends today experience God’s inward work in us today with the power that was so evident among First Friends? God is presumably no different! What is preventing us from experiencing this again?
Class #2 – The Breaking Forth of That Power:
Spirit-filled & Spirit-led Worship
Readings:
We will focus on waiting expectant worship, as hearts seek to be knit together in deepening gathered silence — and hope that we may receive divinely-directed & empowered vocal ministry and prayer.
- Brian Drayton, On Living with a Concern for Gospel Ministry: Introduction, Ch.3 on What Does the Ministry Do? or Ch.17 on The Community of Ministers
- Thom Jeavons, On the Exercise of Authority in Ministry — an important talk at Earlham School of Religion about issues for those called to vocal ministry in unprogrammed meetings.
Additional readings (may be more helpful for those new to Friends):
- Marcelle Martin, Shifting to the Heart — a short blog post on gathered worship
- Lewis Benson, On Being Moved by the Spirit to Minister in Public Worship (wonderful advice to those called to speak in meeting) — also short, about 3-4pp.
- Chris Stern, Quaker Worship: We Cannot Do It on Our Own
- Bill Taber’s Introduction to Samuel Bownas’, Qualifications Necessary to a Gospel Minister
- Revolutionary Roots of Quakerism Handout #3 The Silent Assemblies of God’s People (on early Friends’ worship)
- Inward Light section on Worship: inwardlight.org/faith/worship
Class Handout:
I myself… who not by strength of arguments, or by a particular disquisition of each doctrine, and convincement of my understanding thereby, came to receive and bear witness of the truth, but by being secretly reached by this life; for when I came into the silent assemblies of God’s people, I felt a secret power among them, which touched my heart, and as I gave way unto it, I found the evil weakening in me and the good raised up, and so I became thus knit and united unto them, hungering more and more after the increase of this power and life, whereby I might feel myself perfectly redeemed. —Robert Barclay, 1676
The first that enters into the place of your meeting…turn in thy mind to the light, and wait upon God singly, as if none were present but the Lord; and here thou art strong. Then the next that comes in, let them in simplicity of heart sit down and turn in to the same light, and wait in the spirit; and so all the rest coming in, in the fear of the Lord, sit down in pure stillness and silence of all flesh, and wait in the light…. Those who are brought to a pure still waiting upon God in the spirit, are come nearer to the Lord than words are; for God is a spirit, and in the spirit is he worshiped…. In such a meeting there will be an unwillingness to part asunder, being ready to say in yourselves, it is good to be here; and this is the end of all words and writings—to bring people to the eternal living Word. —Alexander Parker, 1660
And this is the manner of their worship. They are to wait upon the Lord, to meet in the silence of the flesh, and to watch for the stirring of his life, and the breakings forth of his power amongst them. And in the breakings forth of that power they may pray, speak, exhort, rebuke, sing, or mourn, and so on, according as the spirit teaches, requires, and gives utterance. —Isaac Penington 1681
We do believe and affirm that some are more particularly called to the work of the ministry and therefore are fitted of the Lord for that purpose, whose work is more constantly and particularly to instruct, admonish, oversee, and watch over their brethren.
—Robert Barclay’s, Apology for True Christian Divinity, Proposition X (“Concerning the Ministry”)
The Gospel is the “power of God to salvation”; it is the life and light of Christ at work, in characteristic ways, to bring us into freedom from spiritual bondage. Gospel ministry is service whose goal is to encourage, support, push, or invite people to seek and respond to the guidance, teaching, and activity of that Light and Life at work in all, right now. It is not merely speaking words in meetings for worship, but, under a sense of obedience to the motions of the Spirit, using words, deeds, or silent striving to help others (and ourselves) forward to the more abundant life that Jesus sought for his disciples, his friends. —Brian Drayton, On Living with a Concern for Gospel Ministry
To faithfully make this witness to authentic spiritual authority and to fruitfully exercise our callings to ministry, preparing God’s people for service and building up the body of Christ, we must strive to abide in the life and power of God from which any authority for ministry must come…. Wouldn’t it be refreshing to be amazed, as the multitudes were [in response to Jesus’ preaching], by finding persons in [our meetings] speaking “with authority,” with authentic spiritual authority?…
We would find, I think, the attendance and commitment of [true spiritual seekers] in our meetings vastly increased if this power, truth and love was reflected in all the varieties of ministry in our fellowship. We might find all sorts of exciting, enriching, compelling transformations taking place in the fellowship of unprogrammed Friends if ministry and leadership rooted in true spiritual authority were actually welcomed, encouraged and exercised with creativity.
—Thom Jeavons, “On Exercise of Authority in Ministry”
Queries:
- Do you feel Friends recognize true spiritual authority where it is manifest among us today?
- Do you feel ministry rooted in this kind of spiritual authority is welcomed & encouraged in our meetings today? If not, how might this change? How might we help each other in this?
- If “gospel ministry” is a critical piece of the breaking forth of the life & power evident among early Friends, how might we help Friends today understand what this means & discern whether they have a call to this?
Class #3 – Gospel Order: The Structure of Our Meetings
Readings:
George Fox, Margaret Fell & other early Friends set up organizing local meetings. Gospel order is an old Quaker term on how Friends discern ways to live faithfully with each other as a community.
- Lloyd Lee Wilson, “The Quaker Vision of Gospel Order”, Ch.1 of his book, Essays on the Quaker Vision of Gospel Order)
(8 pp. – Wilson made this available to participants in this class and it can be read in the course folder as a .pdf file Please do not share online file beyond this class. You can buy this important book from QuakerBooks here. ) - Sandra Cronk, Gospel Order: A Quaker Understanding of Faithful Church Community up to the section on Mutual Accountability – about 14 pp.)
- Paul Lacey, The Authority of Our Meetings is in the Power of God to end (if you didn’t read all for Class #1) with special attention to the last section called “Gospel Order or Quaker Process?”
- Matt Rosen, The Order of the Day: On Quaker Decision-Making describes how meetings first came to be established and how God was at the center of their meetings for business. (3pp)
Additional readings (focusing mainly on corporate discernment in Meeting for Business):
- Howard Brinton, Reaching Decisions: The Quaker Method, PHP #65, 1952.
- Debbie Humphries, The Four Pillars of Meeting for Business
- Revolutionary Roots Handout #5 on Constructing Gospel Order (as a Way of Living with Each Other)
- Inward Light section on Gospel order at inwardlight.org/faith/gospel-order/
Class Handout:
So, as I was first moved of the Lord God, to go up and down the nation to preach the Gospel, then after[wards] the Lord moved me to go up and down to exhort and unite, that all people might come into the possession of the Gospel, and the Order of it, which is the Power of God…by which`all things are upheld and ordered to the Glory of God.. —George Fox, Epistle #313
Friends, keep your meetings in the power of God, and in his wisdom (by which all things were made) and in the love of God, that by that ye may order all to his glory. And when Friends have finished their business, sit down and continue awhile quietly and wait upon the Lord to feel him. And go not beyond the Power, but keep in the Power by which God Almighty may be felt among you. —George Fox, Epistle #162, 1658
That the power of the God-head may be known in the body, in that perfect freedom which every member hath in Christ Jesus; that none may exercise lordship or dominion over another, nor the person of any be set apart, but as they continue in the power of truth…that truth itself in the body may reign, not persons nor forms: and that all such may be honored as stand in the life of the truth wherein is the power not over, but in the body. —Letter from General Mtg at Skipton for Friends in the North, 1659
Therefore take heed of the world’s fashions, lest ye be moulded up into their spirit, and that will bring you to slight truth, and lift up the wrong eye, and wrong mind, and wrong spirit, and hurt and blind the pure eye, and pure mind, and quench the holy spirit. ` —George Fox, Works, 7:300
In meetings for conducting the business of the Society, decision can be made only when those present reach a state of unity…. It may take weeks or even years to attain such unity…. Unity is eventually possible because every member has access to the same Light of Truth. This Light is not divided, it is One. — Howard Brinton, “Seeds of peace in Quaker worship & decision-making”, Sources of the Quaker Peace Testimony. Pendle Hill Pamphlet #27, 1941
Gospel order is the order established by God that exists in every part of creation, transcending the chaos that seems so often prevalent. It is the right relationship of every part of creation, however small, to every other part and to the Creator. Gospel order is the harmony and order which God established at the moment of creation, and which enables the individual aspects of creation to achieve that quality of being which God intended from the start, about which God could say that “it was very good.” —Lloyd Lee Wilson, Essays on the Quaker Vision of Gospel Order, p.3
The word “order” reverberates with Friends’ multifaceted experience of God’s in-breaking order in their lives. In this context of the corporate and social dimensions of gospel order, the term “order” refers to the characteristics of daily living which flow from God’s life and power and which allow the community to maintain and deepen its relationship with Christ. —Sandra Cronk, Gospel Order: A Quaker Vision of Faithful Church Community, PHP #271, 1991
The practice of discernment among early Friends grew out of this same sense of surrender to a power—a power that changes us and works through us. We were to relinquish our own agendas, yield our own resources, and wait for this transforming power. Everything hinged on an openness to divine surprise, and a willingness to prune what isn’t of God. Setting our plans and anxieties aside, who knew how God might work among us?
—Matt Rosen, Order of the Day: On Quaker Decision-making, 2023
Queries:
- What might be signs that Friends in your local meeting—or yearly meeting—are (or are not) living in gospel order, i.e. in that “quality of being which God intended from the start”—with each other & with the world?
- Cronk sees living patterns that maintain a deep relationship with God/Christ as a covenantal relationship. Do you feel Friends in your mtg/YM see themselves as in a covenantal relationship with each other and with God?
- What might create among Friends a greater willingness and capacity to view our life with each other in this way —and to actually live into such a covenantal relationship with each other and with God?
Class #4 – Holding Each Other in Love & Truth:
Mutual Accountability & the Healing of Rifts
Readings:
This class will focus on the ways we can help each other live out faithfully God’s leadings in our lives and heal rifts within our faith community. This involves the trust that enables us to be vulnerable and transparent with each other and to accept others’ guidance and support as a gift of love. (a bunch of readings, although all but Cronk are quite short. Read what you can!)
- Sandra Cronk, Gospel Order: A Quaker Understanding of Faithful Church Community beginning with the section on Mutual Accountability to the end of pamphlet (about 20 pp.)
- Annis Bleeke, Gospel Order — a 2003 article focusing especially on issues of accountability & discipline within the faith community (5pp.)
- Making Eldering Transparent — a 9 minute video from Three Rivers Friends Meeting (where class member Emily Savin talks with another Friend how it was experienced by him when she raised a concern with him about a message he gave in meeting previously)
- A Minute of Exercise on Healing Rifts within the Faith Community — reflections on how God can help our meetings overcome even deep rifts – from a Quaker Spring gathering. (4pp)
- Perry Yoder, Comments on Accountability. Sandra Cronk & Wilmer Cooper both cite the value of this Mennonite scholar’s ideas on what it means to be in a covenantal relationship with each other in a faith community & how this opens the door to deep mutual accountability. (4pp – part of Quaker Religious Thought, Vol. 61 on Accountability, 1984.)
(Note: Yoder’s “comments” are a response to Dorothy Craven’s article below.)
Additional readings:
- Thomas Brown, Freedom, Authority, and Submission in the Context of Eldering — a wonderful exploration of many Friends’ resistance to allowing others to help them in faithfulness. (8pp)
- Small groups at the Friends Consultation on Spiritual Authority & Accountability did roleplaying exercises of how to deal with difficult discipline issues that might arise within a meeting: See the Roleplaying Exercises and Small Group Discussions. These could be used by meetings!
- Dorothy Craven’s Accountability: A Biblical Approach explores how willingness is critical to Friends’ openness to being assisted in faithfulness by other Friends, how this relates to exercising our gifts, and how this undergirds our the spiritual basis of our testimonies as Friends. (12pp – part of Quaker Religious Thought, Vol. 61 on Accountability, 1984.
Class Handout:
Our life is love, and peace, and tenderness; and bearing one with another, and forgiving one another, and not laying accusations one against another; but praying one for another, and helping one another up with a tender hand, if there has been any slip or fall; and waiting till the Lord gives sense and repentance, if sense and repentance in any be wanting. Oh! wait to feel this spirit, and to be guided to walk in this spirit, that ye may enjoy the Lord in sweetness, and walk sweetly, meekly, tenderly, peaceably, and lovingly one with another. And then, ye will be a praise to the Lord; and any thing that is, or hath been, or may be, amiss, ye will come over in the true dominion, even in the Lamb’s dominion; and that which is contrary shall be trampled upon, as life rises and rules in you. —Isaac Penington, To Friends in Amersham, 1667
The Inward Light of Christ reveals to us our unfaithfulness and sin. This awareness is the beginning of a deeper sensitivity to God’s call and a recognition of our own inward blocks and barriers to faithful response. When Friends followed the process of mutual admonition with each other, they felt they were following the prophetic mode of Christ’s work in human lives….
In the Marlborough story only the power of forgiving love was able to restore the relationship and thus allow a possibility of changed behavior. Forgiveness arises out of reliance on God’s gift of reconciling love to us.
—Sandra Cronk “The Process of Mutual Accountability”, 1995
As one acknowledges the sovereignty of God and experiences it in one’s own life, living in obedience as part of God’s people is an inseparable part of that experience….
In our individualistic culture we tend to forget that God does not speak to me alone. She is not my private oracle. God is not about the business of calling out little autonomous individuals, but is about the business of nourishing bonds and building bodies. This is basic to the biblical understanding of accountability. The focus of accountability seen in this light is to build the committed community.
—Perry Yoder, “Comments on Accountability”, 1985
The rift is over. What underlies peace in the meeting community is trust in God. With that trust there is no need to defend our walls and positions because there is nothing there but God’s power and love. It starts with recognizing our need of God and God’s trustworthiness. If we live in that trust, it spreads out and fills the gaps between us.
A Friend once gave ministry in meeting about the wrongness of walls erected within the faith community and the need to tear them down. A stranger came up to her after meeting and said, “You are wrong about that. The victory is already won.” We don’t have to solve or fix the walls as Christ has already walked through them. —Quaker Spring, Healing of Rifts within the Faith Community, 2011
Queries:
- What is your experience with offering or receiving “eldering” or other forms of help with faithfulness from others? What made it a positive experience or less so?
- Are there rifts in your local or YM? How are they being handled? Is it in “gospel order”?
- (And from last week…) What might create among Friends a greater willingness and capacity to view our life with each other as a covenantal relationship with each other and with God?
Class #5 – This Is Our Testimony to the World:
Transforming the world into the “Gospel Order of Creation”
Readings:
- Sandra Cronk, Peace Be with You: A Study of the Spiritual Basis of the Friends Peace Testimony, 1984. (32 pp.)
- Prophetic Climate Action Working Group, Nine Principles of the Lamb’s War – on how Quakers might today learn from early Friends’ vision of the Lamb’s War and apply it to our work for social transformation today, 2018. (1 page)
- James Nayler, Not to Strive but to Overcome by Suffering, 1658. (1 page)
- “Being Leaven” is the final short chapter of Paul Buckley’s Primitive Quakerism Revived, 2018. (1 page)
- Brian Drayton, On Becoming a Witnessing Body: A Letter to Friends, 2012. (3pp.)
Additional readings:
- Michael Birkel, Mysticism & Activism: Learning from John Woolman, is the 2002 Michener Lecture. On Woolman’s description of what it means to have a “feeling sense” for the condition of others & on action as worship and worship as a path into action (about 20 pp.)
- Marion McNaughton, An Orientation to Prophecy is an address to FWCC Triennial in Dublin in 2007. Describes what prophecy is and how Quakers might grow to be a strong prophetic voice in the world again today, (10 pp.)
- Revolutionary Roots of Quakerism Handout #5 This Is Our Testimony to the World (2pp.)
- Inward Light section on Testimony inwardlight.org/witness/testimony as well as Witness sections on Truth/Integrity, Justice, Peace, and Simplicity.
Class Handout:
We do earnestly desire and wait, that, by the Word of God’s power, and its effectual operation in the hearts of men, the kingdoms of this world may become the kingdoms of the Lord, and of his Christ; that he may rule and reign in men by his Spirit and truth; that thereby all people, out of every profession, may be brought into love and unity with God, and one with another; and that they may all come to witness the prophet’s words, who said, “Nation shall not lift up sword against nation, neither shall they learn war any more.” —Declaration to King Charles II, 1660
“Oh you Rulers & Judges, do you think to overcome us by keeping [our teachers and ring leaders] in prison?. Nay, Christ is our teacher, and he cannot be removed into a corner… The Lord does not speak to us in an unknown tongue, but in our own language do we hear him perfectly, whose voice is better than life… We cannot own the teaching that is of this world, but that which cometh immediately from God, and that is pure and refresheth the soul… and it causeth us to meet together, to worship the Lord as we ought to do.” —Esther Biddle The Trumpet of the Lord Sounded Forth unto These Three Nations, 1662
A tree may grow high and hard and strong, yet fruitless and out of the power, got above the poor, above the innocent, and out of the feeling of the sufferer and man of sorrows where he is. The end of this growth is not in the pure rest, for the higher any one grows here, the more doth that wither and die in them, which is soft and tender & melting, which makes one [a true lamb] and is the true fold for lambs, where the lions must lie down in the end if they come to rest. That eye…which looks to be great among men comes not into the rest, but hath strife in the mind, strife in words and secret smitings, which defile the rest, and lead into the division and separation — but the little child leads into the rest, and that which is lowly gives the entrance. —James Nayler, Not to strive but to overcome by suffering, from 9th epistle, 1658
The root of this peace testimony is deep. It draws its nourishment from the power of God to bring transformation and healing into our inverted and wounded lives, from our deepening experience of Christ’s love, and from our willingness to yield our lives to the guidance of the Holy Spirit. Only as this testimony remains rooted deep in its nourishing soil is it able to produce fruit. In a world which desires the fruit but does not understand the root of the peace testimony, we who would live this witness must take care not to succumb to the notion that the fruit can exist independent of the root.
—Sandra Cronk, Peace Be With You: A Study The Spiritual Basis of the Friends Peace Testimony, 1984.
We need each other, as a body needs all its parts. And Christ, the head, needs our feet and hands and eyes — and these need the head, and the life that circulates and nourishes all parts in one enlivening stream. It is from this mutual need and experience of the common life that a witnessing body is fed and grows in strength, not by declaration or by assertion of unity. These articulate hope, or announce our condition, but cannot create or substitute for the shared living, the actual spiritual organism.
—Brian Drayton. On Becoming a Witnessing Body: A Letter to Friends, 2012
Queries:
- Do you unite with Paul Buckley’s belief that Quakers are “a chosen people called to fulfill a divine purpose” (as God has called other peoples for other purposes)?
- What might it take for us to become, as Brian Drayton says, a witnessing body, “acting as one body united by a common life and gathered by the holy Spirit”?
- How might we, as Nayler says, come to “feel that which is lowly & meek to arise above self and still all strife in our minds”?
- How may we be touched, as Sandra Cronk says, by Christ’s healing power and brought into the peaceable kingdom — to enable us to bear one another’s burdens and help the peaceable kingdom to emerge in our midst — and around us in the world?
Appendix
The following was read at the conclusion of the final class:
Psalm 132 (re-imagined for Friends today)
1 O Living God at the heart of all,
recall to us the hardships our founding parents endured for Truth’s sake,
2 How those women & men vowed to the God they encountered speaking in their hearts, saying:
3 “We will not enter our houses or get into bed,
4 We will not give sleep to our eyes or slumber to our eyelids
5 Until we find a place for the Beloved, a dwelling place for the Heart of our Hearts amongst us.”
6 We first learned this way to have God speak to us and guide our community centuries ago.
Our founders found God in their hearts, in their worship, in their life together!
7 They said “Let us go together to this new place,
this new way of worshiping, this new way of living,
where we found that God had come to teach us directly — experimentally!
8 We know you are still here amongst us as you ever were.
We will make space once again in our hearts, our lives, our meetings
— a resting place for you in the building, the body that is your people.
9 Let your people be clothed with justice. Let your faithful shout for joy!
10 As your partners in new creation, help us keep our faces turned toward you.
Anoint us with your love and with your prophetic vision and power.
11 God swore to First Friends an oath from which She will never turn back:
12 “If you keep the covenant I have made with you and the living teachings that I give you,
I will dwell with you forever.
13 I have chosen the Children of Light, the Publishers of Truth
as my resting place and my habitation,
14 Chosen not you alone, but all people who are attending to the Inward Light of Truth.
15 I will abundantly bless your times of worship and witness to the world.
I will fill your hearts with hope and strength when you are brought low or feel dismayed.
16 Your grownups and children will be clothed with vision. Your faithful will shout for joy!
17 I will cause a horn to sprout up among you to the nations.
I have prepared a lamp to lead you.
18 Your fears and timidity will vanish.
You will find your voice once again.”
—Peter Blood-Patterson, March 2025
This psalm was included in an article entitled “Coming Out from under Our Bushel: Becoming Publishers of Truth Again” for the June 2025 Friends Journal issue on Quaker revival. Read the original Psalm 132 about King David and his descendent.
About the Class
This class was originally taught during April 2025 as part of the Spring Term at Pendle Hill. About fifteen Friends took part in person and another twenty online. Another twenty students had to be turned away for reasons of space. The class participants included Friends with many different theological backgrounds from Christ-centered to Jewish and Buddhist Friends, many levels of experience with Quakerism, and at least seven yearly meetings.
About the Author
Peter Blood-Patterson is a member of Mt Toby Friends Meeting in New England Yearly Meeting. He has a recognized ministry of adult religious education and spiritual formation. This work is under the care of an Oversight of Ministry Committee of that meeting. He travels among Friends with a minute of travel under religious concern from Mt Toby Meeting and New England YM.
